Service was excellent. Genuinely Irish accents and hospitality. I got the pastrami and fries. The pastrami by itself was a bit bland, but the mustard compliments the sandwich very well and some of the best fries I've ever had. Over all an excellent experience. I've been to Ireland and this is probably as close as you're gonna get this side of the pond.

This place is deadly grand! We visited this fine Irish pub before going to a Madison Square Garden concert- a stone's throw away. The management is smart and plays the music of the MSG headliner to get you in the mood for the show. We started with a few tasty Smithwick beers and then had a tasty chicken pot pie and greasy but excellent fish and chips served by a very attentive (Irish) server. The place sports many Irish-themed decor, and the vibe is upbeat and friendly. I highly recommend this place, especially before a MSG concert!

Finished a great night of touring New York here. The place was lit up with folks who just came back from Billy Joel's 150th show at Madison Square Garden and the end of his residency. It was all Billy Joel music, great pints of beer, and excellent cocktails. Their take on the Manhattan was rich and delicious. Bartender was great and took good care of our little group of 3. Super cool vibe, quality Irish Pub! I would definitely hang out here again.

I was meeting up with a friend that I hadn't seen in some time, and we both came through Penn Station. We wanted somewhere to eat and chat for a while. Molly Wee Pub turned out to be perfect. Just a block and a half from Penn, we had no trouble finding a table just before noon. We were greeted warmly by the staff, and shown to our table. We both had the Irish Breakfast. It was an absolutely huge plate of food! It was also really good. The sausages and the black pudding were my favorites. We had some good coffee and stayed quite a long time. The staff would check in from time to time, but they really left us to chat. We never felt rushed. If you are looking for a really solid Irish pub, and you find yourself near Penn Station, I would urge you to give them a try.

It's a no frills Irish pub we wandered into the other weekend. I've personally never been here and had walked by and wondered about it. I think it's probably convenient for shows and games at Madison Square Gardens because it doesn't seem like the type of place that gets typically packed. But the prices are apt for MSG. Most of everything on tap was at $9 and I made the mistake of getting a hard seltzer can that was priced at $10. Yikes. The food looked and smelled good. Someone at the bar had ordered some kind of lamb or pork dish and mashed potatoes that were requested to be covered in melted cheese and at the time I thought that was a genius maneuver. Why have I never requested this? Cute old fashioned juke box. It's definitely a huge Rangers bar. I appreciate places that are focused on hockey as opposed to soccer or football. Brendan Shannahan's jersey is sitting on the wall. You know, that time when he became a traitor to the Red Wings and joined the dark side. I bet he was a regular at one point in life at a joint like this. Definitely worth checking out.

Such a great little pub. Service is Irish. Meaning they will treat you like family, and joke with you as well. The food is nice and hardy. Bartender is a gas, meaning hilarious. I don't want to get her in trouble with anything she said, but we were having a right laugh. We will definitely come back here if we are in the area just for the camaraderie and ambiance. It was such a chill, fun place. Prices were very normal. Drinks were perfect. Bathrooms were clean.

What a great spot, and it's located right next store to MSG, so a great place to stop when going to a concert. I recently went to see Depeche Mode at MSG with a friend. I was super excited to stop by here as my husband use to frequent this spot in his younger days. (LOL) We each got a double drink before heading into the show, as well as, a bite to eat. I got a corn beef sandwich, and it was pretty good. I'd say for NYC the prices were definitely pretty good. I'd definitely stop in here again!